Toilet Troubles: 5 Signs It’s Time to Replace Your Toilet

Toilet Replacement in Ballston, NY | All Star Plumbing - iStock-1325194849

From stinky clogs, unexpected leaks, overflowing bowls, and other headache-inducing problems, the last thing you want to deal with is an ill-functioning toilet. Even though we’re plumbers, we get it. A bathroom that doesn’t work can be quite an inconvenience and even more so—annoying. I mean, c’mon, we live in the revolutionary age of technology and indoor plumbing! 

Luckily, you can avoid toilet conundrums by learning some of the top warning signs it’s time to replace your toilet. That way, your porcelain throne is never out of commission, especially when you need it most! Keep on reading to learn more about the average toilet lifespan and the top five problems that may mean it’s time to replace your toilet from the experts at All Star Plumbing

What Is the Average Lifespan of a Toilet?

Toilets can last up to 50 years! While that sounds like a long time, many toilets only offer 10 to 15 years of prime use but may offer more depending on the level of upkeep and maintenance. You can check inside the tank, towards the top, for a date and manufacturer information if you're unsure when your toilet was installed.

Additionally, the quality of the toilet may impact its lifespan. As the saying goes, “You get what you pay for,” this sure rings true for your toilet. While you won’t have to drop hundreds of dollars on a latrine, you should invest in a high-quality toilet that is up to the challenge. 

What Are the Signs You Need a Toilet Replacement?

Now that you’ve got a good idea of the lifespan of your favorite plumbing appliance, let’s take a look at some of the red flags to watch out for. And yes, these are just toilet red flags. Sadly, we’re only experts in plumbing—not relationships.


Unlike your grandma, toilets don’t always age gracefully. As we mentioned above, it’s important to be aware of how old your toilet is so when it reaches the end of its expected lifespan, you’re already prepared to buy a replacement. And while a replacement may seem like an investment, it can actually save you big bucks in the long run. If you replace your toilet before it leaks or cracks, you can avoid future damage to your home’s pipes, floors, and other inner workings. 

Constant Clogs

While using your plunger after a much-need bathroom break isn’t unusual, it may be time for a replacement if you constantly have to unclog your toilet. If this is you, we recommend calling your trusted local plumbing company, like All Star Plumbing. An experienced professional can inspect your toilet, examine the pipes, and let you know if you require a new and shiny pot. And, if your kid decided to have a field day in the bathroom and shove their toys down the toilet, creating a hard-to-reach clog, we can help with that too. 

Tank Cracks

Tank cracks are one of the most obvious (and easily spotted) signs it’s time for a toilet replacement. If you notice any splits, fissures, or chinks in the lower to the bottom portion of your toilet, we advise calling a plumber as soon as you can. These cracks can quickly turn into uncontrollable leaks, which can be quite a pain to deal with. Big or small, call All Star Plumbing for any noticeable damages at (518) 864-1224.


Like spotting a needle in a haystack, leaks aren’t always obvious, making them harder to spot. However, your water bill can be an easy indicator that something’s not right. If your significant other hasn’t been taking annoyingly long showers, but your water bill is still high, you may have a toilet leak. When in doubt, we recommend contacting a plumber to ensure your plumbing is in tip-top shape. 

Frequent Calls

At All Star Plumbing, we like to say we’re a judgment-free zone. Whenever you have a plumbing problem, don’t hesitate to call us. But, if you’re dialing us weekly for various toilet issues, we recommend it’s time to replace your toilet. While we’re always happy to help, replacing your toilet is more cost-effective than spending money trying to repair it. The next time we visit (or even if you’re a first-time customer), we’ll always let you know if we think a replacement is your best option.  

What Should You Do If You Need a Toilet Replacement?

We hope that with these tips, you can stay busy with life's fun, enjoyable activities rather than dealing with frustrating toilet problems. But, even with perfect preparation, sometimes, life happens. If you experience a plumbing catastrophe, keep calm and rest easy, knowing All Star Plumbing offers 24/7 emergency plumbing service. Whether it’s an overflowing toilet or drainage backup, we’re a team of experts you can trust! For more information about toilet replacements or other plumbing Qs, get in touch with us today!

Do You Need a Toliet Replacement? Call the Plumbing Pros!

Proudly serving Ballston, NY & the surrounding areas, All Star Plumbing is here to repair and replace your toilet disasters. From toilet cracks to leaks and more, we’re proud to get the job done right—the first time. Call us at (518) 864-1224 or contact us online to schedule an appointment with one of our friendly, certified professionals.

Water Heater Repair & Installation

Your Hot Water Heater - Silent Hero Hot water is more than a convenience in your home as it’s a necessity for doing the dishes, daily cleaning, washing clothes, bathing, and cooking. The fact that your water heater operates silently behind...

All Star Plumbing For All Your Drains

All Star Plumbing is proud to announce the addition of complete cleaning services. All star now has a drain specialist on staff for all of your drain needs including main sewer lines.  We service drains in all fo Saratoga county including...

Is A Tankless Water Heater Right For You

A Tankless Water Heater is one of the most efficient water distribution units and an effective source of hot water in homes and businesses in Clifton Park, New York. These innovative devices deliver 2 to 5 gallons of water per minute, only when a...

Welcome to Our New Website!

We've added great new features and updated our content to bring you the most up to date information about our company.  Check back often for updates.
Reasonable and fair and definitely honest. Overall great experience. Have been looking for a good plumber since moving here and now we found them.
5.0 Rating!
Customer Service"
I will say wholeheartedly that this was by far the most exceptional customer service I have ever received…which says a lot because we have had some great companies do work for us. I would highly recommend Nate and All Star Plumbing. Thank you Nate!
5.0 Rating!
"Doesn't Get
Better Than This!!"
Phenomenal! Professional! Above and beyond what was requested…great skill in plumbing -I would say work shows perfectionist at work and aims to please!! Perfect ten rating!
5.0 Rating!

5 Star Service
Plan Membership
Join TODAY and start receiving
these Members Only Benefits:
  • Priority Service
  • 10% Off All Repairs
  • 2 Year Warranty
  • Peace of Mind Home Inspection
  • Water Heater Maintenance
  • No Overtime/Weekend/After Hours Rates